Skip to content
Ryan Smith, DDS

Verdict index

Every verdict, one page.

The question, the answer and how much to trust it, for every episode. Sort by evidence to see what is settled; open the card for the Monday-morning protocol on one printable page.

17 of 17 episodes

Question and verdictCard
17Is Single-Visit Endo as Successful as Multi-Visit?

For routine root canal treatment, finishing in one visit heals about as well as spreading it over two or more.

EndoStrong

a 47-trial Cochrane review, a corroborating meta-analysis, and a dedicated RCT

Print card
16Is Warm Vertical Better Than Single Cone?

For routine canals, single cone with a high-quality bioceramic sealer heals, hurts, and survives about the same as warm vertical compaction, and it does it in roughly half the chair time.

EndoModerate

three RCTs from two research groups, one systematic review

Print card
15Should We Use Posts or Not?

A post does not strengthen a root-canal-treated tooth.

EndoModerate

six systematic reviews, no dedicated large RCT

Print card
14Digital CAD/CAM vs. Traditional Crowns

Hold the material constant (same lithium disilicate, same cement), and digital and conventional crown workflows produce statistically equivalent marginal fit, internal adaptation, and survival.

CrownsStrong

three meta-analyses and a matched cohort agree

Print card
13Is Amalgam Bad or Not?

Two large randomized trials (five and seven years of follow-up, real children, not rats) found no statistically significant difference in IQ, memory, kidney function, or nerve conduction between kids restored with amalgam and kids restored with composite.

MaterialsStrong

two RCTs and a Cochrane review

Print card
12Can You Bond to Sclerotic Dentin?

Bond strength to sclerotic dentin really is lower than to sound dentin.

MaterialsModerate

two systematic reviews, no dedicated RCT

Print card
11Do Deeper Fillings Really Need Liners?

For routine Class I and II composite restorations, adding a cavity liner does not measurably reduce post-operative sensitivity or improve survival: a Cochrane review and an independent 341-patient RCT both say so.

RestorativeModerate

a Cochrane review and three corroborating RCTs, no long-term follow-up

Print card
10Is Bulk-Fill as Good as Incremental Layering?

Used per manufacturer instructions, bulk-fill composite performs about as well as conventional 2 mm incremental layering on annual failure rate, marginal integrity, and post-operative sensitivity.

MaterialsStrong

a 5-year RCT and a meta-analysis of ten studies

Print card
09Is Your Old Curing Light Sabotaging Your Fillings?

A meaningful share of curing lights in active clinical use (old ones especially, but not only old ones) deliver less light energy than the composite at the bottom of a Class II box needs to fully polymerize.

MaterialsModerate

real-world surveys plus in vitro physics, no clinical RCT

Print card
08Does Gluma Reduce Post-Op Sensitivity In Dental Fillings?

Applied before a modern adhesive, Gluma desensitizer measurably plugs dentinal tubules in vitro, and several small trials show a real reduction in sensitivity in the first days to weeks.

MaterialsModerate

two long RCTs against three short, smaller ones

Print card
07When Does a Tooth Actually Need a Crown Instead of Just a Filling?

Two of the four "red lines" for crowning instead of filling hold up on verified data: a definitive crack (early crowning measurably improves survival over years, not just anecdotally) and a posterior tooth after root canal treatment (uncrowned teeth are extracted at six times the rate of crowned ones).

RestorativeModerate

several large retrospective cohorts and one meta-analysis, no randomized trial

Print card
06Do Glass Ionomers Actually Remineralize Dentin?

Glass ionomers really do remineralize caries-affected dentin.

MaterialsModerate

a small systematic review and converging in vitro/in vivo studies, no clinical outcome trial

Print card
05Immediate vs. Delayed Implants (Is There a Penalty?)

The two best answers to "does immediate placement carry a penalty" genuinely disagree, and pretending otherwise would be dishonest.

ImplantsModerate

one systematic review and one long-term single-center cohort disagree

Print card
04Does Silver Diamine Fluoride Really Arrest Caries Long-Term?

Silver diamine fluoride arrests active caries in the majority of lesions it's applied to, and it holds up over years, not just at the six-month recheck.

PreventionStrong

three concordant systematic reviews and a large RCT

Print card
03How Long Do Crowns Really Last?

A crown placed today has a realistic shot at 90% survival at 5 years, somewhere around 80% at 10, and just over 60% at 20: numbers that come from a 1,037-crown cohort followed for more than a decade on average, backed by two systematic reviews of thousands more.

CrownsStrong

two systematic reviews and two multi-decade cohort studies

Print card
02Do Patients Really Need a 6-Month Recall? (The Case for 12)

The largest and best-designed trial ever run on this question (2,372 adults, 51 UK practices, 4 years of follow-up) found no meaningful difference in caries, gum bleeding, or quality of life between patients recalled every 6 months, every 24 months, or on an individualized risk-based schedule.

PreventionStrong

one large RCT and a concordant Cochrane review

Print card
01Should You Leave Caries Behind? (The End of Complete Excavation)

For deep carious lesions in vital, asymptomatic teeth, selective caries removal beats complete excavation on the outcomes that matter (pulp exposure and overall failure), and does at least as well as the more time-consuming stepwise technique.

RestorativeStrong

a Cochrane review, a second meta-analysis, an RCT, and a national guideline

Print card

Each verdict is the opening sentence of the episode’s own verdict box. The full article carries the studies, the numbers and the caveats; read it before you change a protocol.

The Dental Grind

Every Monday, free: how a practice actually works, plus the podcast.